Had Bill run the argument by more sophisticated Christian theologians, they would have pointed out that (a) he shouldn’t make such a flawed argument (b) doing so makes Christians look like simpletons.
Here’s my tweet and Bill Morgan’s response:
@ReasonOnFaith always puzzling,why an atheist killed my another atheist –https://t.co/dpmW9JIzZs
— Bill Morgan (@billrmorgan)
Has a Christian never killed another Christian? A Hindu?
To make any kind of point here, you’d have to point to specific atheist doctrine. But that doesn’t even exist. Clearly, you don’t even understand what atheism is.
All atheism is, is a rejection of a theist’s God claim, based on a lack of evidence for such claim.
There is no secret Atheist bible with passages in it of moral depravity that create the conditions for or instruct atheists to do good things or bad things.
Your argument shows a poverty of thinking: just because you subscribe to a codified belief system and worldview, does not mean that everyone else that disagrees with you also subscribes to a structured, codified manifesto for life.
We can talk for hours about exactly the kind of moral depravity you allude to, which is actually supported by the God of the Old Testament. The God who, according to you, is Jesus in his earlier non-human manifestation as Yahweh.
I’d like to suggest that people in glass houses shouldn’t throw stones.